Where is Julie Baumeister today? All about Herbert Baumeister's ex-wife
Where is Julie Baumeister today? Julie currently lives in Fishers, Indiana. She was married to Herbert Baumeister, who was accused of targeting and killing young men from Indiana’s gay community during the 1990s.

Source: Instagram
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Key takeaways
- Julie was married to Herbert, the Indiana businessman suspected of murdering several young men in the 1990s.
- After filing for divorce in 1996, Julie allowed authorities to search their property. This led to the discovery of human remains at Fox Hollow Farm.
- From 1997, Julie worked various jobs, including roles at Gap Inc. and Old Navy, before establishing a long-term career as a personal banker at Old National Bank.
- As of the latest information, Julie lives in Fishers, Indiana, and maintains a low profile.
Julie Baumeister’s profile summary
Full name | Julie Saiter Baumeister |
Gender | Female |
Current residence | Fishers, Indiana |
Nationality | American |
Ethnicity | White |
Religion | Christianity |
Sexual orientation | Straight |
Relationship status | Divorced |
Ex-husband | Herbert Baumeister |
Children | 3 |
Famous for | Being the wife of a suspected serial killer |
Profession | Banker |
Herb Baumeister's wife today
Julie currently lives in Fishers, Indiana. She married Herbert in November 1971, and they had three children. In June 1996, she filed for divorce after growing suspicious of her husband's possible involvement in a series of missing persons cases. She began working at Gap Inc. in 1997 and later joined Old Navy. In 2005, she became a Personal Banker I at Old National Bank.

Source: Instagram
Julie Baumeister and Herb Baumeister's relationship and dark secrets
The couple lived in Westfield, Indiana, at a property known as Fox Hollow Farm. On the surface, Baumeister appeared to be a committed father and a regular churchgoer.
However, Julie later revealed that their physical relationship was minimal; in over twenty-five years of marriage, they were only close on a handful of occasions. She also noted that she had never seen her husband fully undressed.
Just six months after their wedding, Baumeister’s father had him admitted to a psychiatric facility for two months. Julie later described it as when her husband was distraught and needed help.
As their relationship gradually stabilised, the couple secured a loan from Herb’s mother and, in 1988, opened their first Sav-A-Lot thrift store. They worked long hours and eventually opened a second location. Their success allowed them to move to the more secluded Fox Hollow Farm in 1992.
Over the years, Julie began to notice troubling behaviour in her husband. She recounted moments when he was harsh toward others and even cut off his mother for four years following a disagreement.
Julie also recalled occasions when, after arguments, Herb would take their children out and leave her at home alone. The first major incident that raised concern was when their son and a friend discovered a skull in the wooded area behind their house.
When Julie went to check, she found multiple fragments of what appeared to be human bones. Herb explained that they were his father’s medical specimens, a former anaesthesiologist.
Though sceptical, Julie admitted she didn't know how to react then. Unbeknownst to her, her husband would later become the main suspect in a series of disappearances involving young men from Indiana's gay community.
As the police investigation intensified, their business and marriage began to deteriorate. When law enforcement initially requested to search the property, Julie and Herb refused permission.
In June 1996, Julie filed for divorce after suspecting that her husband may have been connected to the missing persons cases. She ultimately gave investigators consent to search the estate.
They discovered thousands of bone fragments across different parts of the woods behind their home. Herb died by self-murder after a warrant was issued for his arrest.
Is Julie Baumeister still alive?
Yes, Julie Baumeister (born Julie Saiter) is still alive. After her divorce from Herbert in 1996, she chose to live a private life in Fishers, Indiana.
Herb Baumeister's kids
Herb had three children (names undisclosed). His dark and secretive side began to come to light in 1994 when his 13-year-old son discovered a skull and bones in the wooded area behind their $1 million estate, Fox Hollow Farm, in Westfield, Indiana.
Was Julie Baumeister on Oprah Winfrey show?
No sources indicate that Julie Baumeister appeared on The Oprah Winfrey Show or any of Oprah Winfrey's subsequent reality programs, such as Oprah's Lifeclass, Super Soul Sunday, or Oprah's Master Class.
FAQs about Julie and Herbert Baumeister
- Who was Herbert Baumeister? Herbert Baumeister was an Indiana businessman who became the prime suspect in a series of murders targeting young men, many from the LGBTQ+ community, during the 1980s and 1990s.
- What was Herbert Baumeister accused of? Herbert Baumeister was accused of luring young men from gay bars in Indianapolis to his property, Fox Hollow Farm, where he allegedly murdered them.
- What happened to Herbert Baumeister? Herbert Baumeister fled to Ontario, Canada. In July 1996, he died by self-murder at a park.
- How many victims are linked to Baumeister? At least 11 victims were linked to Baumeister. However, authorities believe the actual number of victims could be higher, potentially up to 20 or more.
- Has there been any media coverage or documentaries about him? Yes, there are several true crime documentaries, podcasts, and TV series about him, including The Ghost Adventures episode at Fox Hollow Farm and Netflix's Unsolved Mysteries.
Final word
Where is Julie Baumeister today? After her 1996 divorce from Herbert, Julie quietly rebuilt her personal and professional life. She established a long-term career in banking and resides in Fishers, Indiana.
Tuko.co.ke has published an article about Maura Murray's disappearance and the ongoing search. Maura, a 21-year-old nursing student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, disappeared on February 9, 2004, after a car crash in Haverhill, New Hampshire. Despite searches and countless theories, no one knows what happened that night. Read this article for more details.
Source: TUKO.co.ke